So am I to believe that after all these years of avoiding watching American Idol, that girls that look like Katherine McPhee have been the contestants? If that’s the case, why didn’t someone tell me?
I Googled Katherine McPhee and apparently she didn’t win American Idol the year she was on there. WTF? Are you serious??? How can she not have won? I mean…. look at her! It saddens me to think what this country has come to. It just isn’t the American way to have someone this hot not win a singing contest. 
If I were Simon Cowell and Katherine McPhee came in to audition looking like this, I would have immediately handed over the trophy and asked her to marry me.
-Dave Q.
Maybe if she had looked like that during the contest she would have won?
Google the “bikini girl” who tried out last year. She didn’t even make the finalists! LOL!
yes…she is very beautiful. I like her with darker hair though.
mmmm mmmm looks good to me!
Yeah. That was the only year I ever watched some of American Idol. She totally should have won it – both for singing ability AND looks!!!